The reviews for Turtle Bay Newcastle highlight a consistent positive experience regarding food allergy management. Customers have expressed appreciation for the staff's attentiveness and willingness to go the extra mile to accommodate specific dietary needs. Instances like finding coconut for cocktails for a customer allergic to dairy demonstrate a commitment to safety and satisfaction.

Multiple reviewers noted that the staff provided extensive assistance, with servers taking the time to check ingredients and options for those with allergies, such as nut or chilli allergies. This careful approach instilled confidence in diners, allowing them to relax and enjoy their meals.

While some reviewers mentioned that options can be limited due to allergy restrictions, the overall sentiment remains positive. Patrons felt that the variety available was still commendable, with many expressing their desire to return despite minor limitations. The emphasis on customer service amidst these restrictions was a key theme.

Overall, Turtle Bay Newcastle seems to successfully combine a vibrant dining atmosphere with a strong focus on accommodating food allergies, resulting in a safe and enjoyable experience for customers with dietary concerns.